Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Dollhouse, week 8

Better this week.

For the first time, I was genuinely surprised by the ending, in a way that was satisfying. Part of that was clever misdirection -- I jumped to the wrong conclusion about the scenario Adelle was running, as I no doubt was intended to -- but part of it was that I still don't entirely trust the writers, so when Echo and co. started making ridiculous choices ("We have no idea who or where we are, so let's split up!"), I took it for bad storytelling rather than a clue to what was really going on.

Dominic's line about why it's better to think of the dolls as pets was my favorite bit of business, but it also underscores one of my ongoing issues with the show, which is that there seems to be a mismatch between the nature of the Dollhouse and the character of the people (especially the handlers) who work for it.

The nearest real-world analogy to what the Dollhouse is, seems to me, is a brothel staffed by slave labor, one of those deals where women are lured into traveling overseas for what they think is a modeling career, only to discover, too late, that they're actually going to be unpaid prostitutes. The Dollhouse uses sci-fi mind-control in place of threats and physical abuse, but morally and practically, it's the same sort of enterprise.

The attitudes and behavior of the Dollhouse staff, on the other hand -- Amy Acker's objection to Dominic's use of a dehumanizing metaphor; Topher's belief that the terms of the dolls' contracts will be honored; the distinction everyone seems to draw between Sierra's rape by her handler and the equally non-consensual sex acts she and the other dolls regularly perform with clients -- all of that seems more appropriate to a legal but corrupt business, like a state-licensed Nevada brothel being run by mobsters. I could see average-Joe (and -Jane) doctors, tech people, and security guards signing up to work at a place like that and maintaining a distinction between acceptable and unacceptable exploitation of the dolls. I could also see them turning a blind eye to evidence that the management regularly breaks the law and abuses the dolls -- but the more of that evidence they see, the more important it becomes that they be able to maintain the fiction that what they're doing is OK.

One way to create and preserve such a fiction in the context of what is clearly a criminal enterprise would be to convince employees that the Dollhouse is a technically illegal but still legitimate business, e.g., a scientific research facility that uses volunteer subjects to conduct important research that has been unreasonably suppressed by the government. Even if you could convince people that this sexual fantasy factory is serving a higher good, though, I'm not sure why you'd want to. Wouldn't it make more sense to just admit you're engaged in a felony enterprise, and hire people who don't have a problem with that?


Apr. 4th, 2009 09:31 pm (UTC)
I first misread "like a corrupt legal business" to mean a corrupt law firm, which would certainly fit in with Joss's other worlds. I agree that Joss always talks about what is legal vs. moral vs. ethical, and the Dollhouse certainly upholds that tradition.

Would it really be better to say that it's technically illegal? Maybe. But aren't there lots of people who get thrills out of moving through the grey areas? (E.g., some of the financial shenanigans that have caused some our current -- and past -- troubles.) Or does Joss have just too much fun with the moral ambiguity (not counting the Evil League of Evil)?
Apr. 5th, 2009 12:14 am (UTC)
I first misread "like a corrupt legal business" to mean a corrupt law firm,

Sorry for the confusion; I've changed the wording to make it less ambiguous.

But aren't there lots of people who get thrills out of moving through the grey areas?

I don't think most people would regard working for the Dollhouse as a grey area, though. They're not selling adjustable-rate mortgages; they're selling (and sometimes killing) human beings.
Apr. 5th, 2009 12:43 am (UTC)
No, the misreading was my brain, not your writing. Still, it got me thinking about Wolfram & Hart, and parallels with Dollhouse. At W&H, though, it's clear that the employees knew that it was a legit business run by bad guys.

Edited at 2009-04-06 04:51 am (UTC)
Apr. 6th, 2009 04:51 am (UTC)
Sorry: I wasn't clear. I was thinking that the clients are attracted by the gray areas (though clearly some think that there is only gray, or something).

And yes, a brothel might work. Or a government agency (though that's been done to death).
Apr. 5th, 2009 07:42 am (UTC)
For me the biggest WTF moment was the revelation that Sierra's indenture is involuntary.

Latest Month

December 2011


Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Tiffany Chow